The Color My Cookie Story

When we got married, we dreamed of having boys, girls & a bakery. Our girls, Catherine and Elisabeth, were born in 2010 and 2014. Our boys, Peter and Andrew, were born in 2012 and 2017. Along the way, we became bakery owners, too.

When the pandemic forced us to close our storefront bakery in the summer of 2020, we laid off 11 of our 14 employees and started delivering DIY cookie decorating kits from the backs of our cars – and Color My Cookie was born! By the end of 2020, Color My Cookie had shipped to all 50 states and Puerto Rico and had been featured in The Food Network Online, The Today Show Online, Red Tricycle, and more. Our staff had grown back to 10, including several employees we had laid off in the summer.

We want you to feel like a pro cookie decorator – so we give you a bit of a head start! Our cookies are pre-iced, which preserves their freshness and provides the perfect canvas for your creativity. We include everything you need: edible watercolors, icing, edible décor, and an online tutorial where we give you tips & tricks for making your cookies come to life.

You’ll be delighted by your masterpiece, even before your first bite!

We can’t wait to share Color My Cookie with you!

Nancy & Chef Sam