Smart Cookies are Asking ...

When will my Color My Cookie Arrive? 

Your Color My Cookie is baked fresh and will ship within 3-5 days of placing your order. Shipping takes 2 -3 days to most US locations. We ship from Dallas, TX, to the continental United States. 

How Long Will My Cookies Last? 

Your cookies are baked fresh and will be at their softest and most delicious if you eat them within a day or two after receiving them. 

Is Color My Cookie Peanut-free? 

Color My Cookie is peanut free, but our cookies are baked in a kitchen where peanuts and other nuts, including tree nuts, may be present. 

Is Color My Cookie Gluten-free? 

No. Color My Cookie is not gluten-free. We do not currently have a gluten-free Color My Cookie option. Maybe someday! 

What are the Ingredients in Color My Cookie? 

Our cookies are made of Flour, Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Vanilla

The white base icing ingredients are: Powdered Sugar, Water, Meringue Powder, Less than 2% Corn Syrup

The colored icing and decorative element ingredients are: Water, Sugar, Meringue Powder, Less than 2% Artificial Color (one or more of Blue 1, Blue 2, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Red 3, Red 40) 

What if my package says “Delivered” but I don’t have it?

We ship via USPS Priority Mail. In rare cases, USPS may mark a package “Delivered” up to 24 hours before it is actually delivered. Also, sometimes the postal carrier may try to do you a favor and hide your cookies – so please check around potted plants, near porch furniture, and anywhere else you think your postal carrier would think is a good cookie hiding spot. Still no package? Please contact USPS and submit a service request to USPS by email to your local USPS facility for follow-up. You will receive a confirmation number and a contact within 2-3 business days.

Feel free to contact us as well, and once you’ve taken these steps we’ll do our best to get new cookies off to you. We do not offer refunds in the case of missing packages.

Can I Visit Color My Cookie Headquarters? 

We love visitors! If you make it to Dallas and would like to see where the cookie magic happens, email and we'll do our best to make it happen!